Can we all agree that Costco has the best/most unnecessary stuff ever? I mean, yes, there are tons of necessary things like screaming deals on bulk butter, nuts, and even lobster. But they also have things that you don’t really need, but REALLY want once you see them. Take for example the 3 lb tub of Reese’s Pieces I recently bought. Did I technically need 3 lbs worth of peanut butter goodness?? Probably not. Did buying it totally make my day and maybe even life infinitely better?? That’s debatable, but I’m leaning towards yes.
So now you’re probably wondering, “What do you do with 3 lbs worth of Reese’s?” Well, I’m glad you asked. First, you eat it….like a lot of it. Then you hide it from your husband cause he’s eating it faster than you and you’ll be damned if he gets to eat more of it than you (I have candy sharing issues). Then you realize you still have an insane amount of Reese’s Pieces left and should probably figure out a way to use it up. That’s where this recipe comes in.
Lately, I’ve been drooling over all the meringue topped brownies on Instagram and have been wanting to create my own version. Thankfully, my crazy amount of Reese’s Pieces gave me the perfect excuse to do so. Since chocolate and peanut butter is one of the greatest combos of all time, I decided to make a dark chocolate brownie with Reese’s Pieces folded in. And to take the peanut butter flavor up a bit and take the brownies up a notch, I topped them with a peanut butter Swiss meringue.
You guys, I’m not kidding when I say this meringue is legit. It’s the fluffiest, silkiest, most delicious meringue ever. It’s so good that I ate an embarrassing amount straight out of the bowl. And it’s also super easy to make and super stable – which were the two most important things to me when developing the recipe.
So if you have any leftover Reese’s Pieces hanging around after Halloween…..or just need a good excuse to buy that giant 3 lb tub of Reese’s from Costco then this is the recipe for you!